A parent once shared how her young child got really upset when a crayon mark wouldn’t erase. Just one stray line, and the whole drawing felt ruined. Most of us have been in a similar situation, and we’ve probably said, “It’s not a big deal.” But that rarely helps. That’s why I often use a simple question with families: big deal or little deal?

Where Big Deal or Little Deal Comes From

I didn’t come up with this question myself. It comes from Unstuck and On Target, an executive function program created by Lynn Cannon, Lauren Kenworthy, and their team at Children’s National Hospital and the Ivymount School. I use it with families often because it’s so simple and effective.

In the program’s language, a “big deal” is a major problem. It takes a long time to fix and usually takes a lot of people to solve. A little deal is a small problem. It can be fixed quickly and doesn’t require many people. That’s the heart of a big deal or a little deal: the question is really about help. Does this need an adult, or can you handle it yourself?

Why “It’s Not a Big Deal” Backfires

When a parent says “it’s not a big deal,” the child hears that the feeling is wrong. The feeling is real, even when the problem is small. So the child pushes harder to prove it matters, and suddenly we’re arguing about the feeling instead of solving the problem. (I wrote more about how that kind of escalation builds in Emotion Without Chaos.)

Sizing the problem works differently because the child does the sorting, and the feeling stays. The program even suggests saying something like, “It’s OK if something feels like a big deal. I’ll help you figure out how to turn it into a little deal.”

Kids can get surprisingly good at this. I’ve worked with a teen who looked back on a blowup over something he wasn’t allowed to buy and named it himself: he had taken a small problem and made it into a giant one. That kind of insight usually comes after the storm, not during it.

It’s also worth remembering that size is personal. Something that feels small to you might feel huge to your child, and the reverse is true, too.

Putting a size on a problem gives a kid something to think about besides the feeling, and that alone usually takes some of the heat out of it.

Why Small Things Tip Over on Some Days

Some days, a broken pencil is nothing. Other days, it ends the evening. One child I worked with explained the difference using a stress cup: “How full is it today?” On a full-cup day, even a little deal can spill everything over.

Hunger and fatigue fill the cup fast, which is why I keep coming back to HALT. It’s also why the hour after school can be so fragile, as I wrote in The Reboot Ritual.

What Big Deal or Little Deal Looks Like with Older Kids

With teens, the idea holds up, but the words need to grow with them. Plenty of teenagers will roll their eyes at “big deal or little deal,” so keep the thinking and drop the phrase. A few versions that tend to land:

  • “On a scale of 1 to 10, how big is this?”
  • “Is this a today problem or a next-month problem?”
  • “Do you want me to listen, help you think it through, or help fix it?”

That last one matters most. With older kids, the question is still about how much help they need, but they get to decide what kind. The timing changes, too. Teens often size up a problem best after the fact, in the car or late at night, as the teen I mentioned earlier did. The program also has versions for older kids, one for ages 11 to 15 and another for 14 to 22.

When Everything Is a Big Deal

Some kids will answer “big deal” every time, at least at first. Don’t argue about it. Take them at their word and move to the next question: “OK, it’s a big deal. What would help?” Often the answer turns out to be small (a new sheet of paper, five minutes, a hug), and the kid sees that for themselves. It also helps to practice on problems that aren’t theirs, like a character in a show, since kids size other people’s problems more easily than their own. And watch the stress cup. A kid who sees everything as huge may be running on empty. If it keeps happening and interferes with school, friendships, or family life, mention it to your pediatrician or a psychologist. Sometimes “everything is a big deal” is worry talking.

How to Practice at Home

Managing emotions is a skill that has to be taught directly. Kids don’t absorb it on their own. Like any fluency skill, the more they practice it calmly, the easier it is to reach when they’re upset.

So teach before and comfort in the moment. The middle of a meltdown is the worst time to introduce a new idea. Instead, practice when nothing is wrong:

  • Size a problem for a character in a show or a book.
  • Talk through a sibling’s latest “crisis” (out of the sibling’s earshot).
  • Size your own problems out loud. “I spilled my coffee. That’s a little deal. I’ll grab a towel.” 

Then, when the real moment comes, comfort first. Later, once things are calm, ask: “Big deal or little deal?” Let your child answer. And if it really is a big deal, praise them for knowing it needs help.

When this happens repeatedly, it’s easy to start seeing a kid as someone who overreacts. What I usually see is a good kid having a hard time. That crayon-mark parent told me her child was learning that not everything has to be perfect. That takes practice, for kids and for the rest of us.