A parent mentioned something in a session recently that I hear often.
Every afternoon, the routine is the same. The kid gets in the car. Parent asks how the day was. Kid says, “Good.” Parent asks what happened. Kid says “nothing.” Conversation over before it started.
The parent had started to wonder whether something was wrong. Whether their child was hiding something. Whether the relationship was breaking down.
What was actually happening was simpler than that — and it has less to do with how to talk to your kids about their day than it does with how you’re asking the question.
Their child was doing what almost everyone does when someone asks a general question in a general way. They gave a socially acceptable answer and moved on.
“Good” Is a Social Script, Not an Answer
In my work as a psychologist, I tell patients early on that telling me things are “good” gives me nothing to work with. Not because I doubt them, but because “good” is what we say when someone asks how we’re doing as a passing social nicety. It’s the answer that ends a conversation politely rather than beginning one honestly.
Children learn this script early. By the time they’re in elementary school, most kids have already figured out that “good” closes the loop without requiring anything further. It isn’t evasion — not usually. It’s just the path of least resistance when a question doesn’t give them anywhere interesting to go.
The challenge for parents isn’t that children won’t talk. It’s that the questions parents ask most often are exactly the kind that produce one-word answers.
How to Talk to Your Kids About Their Day Starts With the Question
“How was your day?” is a question with an almost infinite scope. A child — particularly one who is tired, hungry, or still processing what happened at school — has no idea where to start. So they don’t. They compress the whole thing into “good” and wait to see if you actually want more.
This is not a communication problem. It’s a design problem.
The question isn’t giving the child enough structure to answer well. And for many children — especially those still developing the executive function skills that help organize thoughts and retrieve memories on demand — a wide-open question like “how was your day?” is genuinely hard to answer, even when they want to.
What looks like a closed-off kid is often a kid who needed a better entry point.
How to Ask Questions That Actually Open Things Up
A few patterns that tend to work better — not as scripts to follow, but as ways of thinking about the question before you ask it:
Get specific and concrete. Instead of “how was your day?” try “what was the most boring part of today?” or “did anything surprising happen at lunch?” Specific questions give children something to aim at. They don’t have to summarize — they just have to recall one thing.
Ask about others, not just themselves. Children who won’t talk about their own experience will often talk about someone else’s. “Did anything weird happen with anyone in your class today?” is a lower-stakes entry point than “how are you feeling?”
Notice and name, rather than ask. Sometimes the most effective move isn’t a question at all. “You seem quieter than usual” or “you look like something’s on your mind” creates space without demanding a response. Children often find it easier to confirm an observation than to generate a report from scratch.
Follow the one word they do give you. In my clinical work, when someone gives me a one-word answer, I get curious about that one word rather than moving past it. If a child says “fine” — what does fine mean for them today? Is fine the same as yesterday’s fine? Following the thread of what they did say often opens more than pushing for something they haven’t said yet.
Let silence do some of the work. One of the hardest lessons in learning to listen well is staying quiet long enough for the other person to fill the space. Most of us move too quickly to the next question when the first one doesn’t land. A pause that feels awkward to you often feels like room to think to a child.
Being Ready for What You Might Hear
There’s a piece of this that parents don’t often think about in advance.
If “good” is no longer an acceptable answer — if you start asking better questions and creating more space — you also have to be ready for what comes next.
Sometimes it’s mundane. Sometimes it’s funny. And occasionally it’s something you weren’t expecting and weren’t sure you wanted to know.
The only thing that keeps children talking over time is the experience of having talked before and having it go well. That means listening without immediately fixing. Without jumping to solutions before the child is done. Without reacting to the hard parts in a way that makes them regret having said anything at all.
Staying non-reactive is genuinely difficult. It is also the only thing that keeps the conversation open the next time.
That doesn’t happen from one better question. It happens from a pattern of them.
If you’re thinking about how to build better communication patterns with your children, how families structure their time together shapes how much conversation happens at all — this post on time pressure and why structure collapses is worth reading alongside this one. And if you’re specifically navigating this with a teenager, there’s more on the Innovative Dad site about why teens communicate the way they do. (Add Week 7 link when published.)
New here? Innovative Dad translates the patterns of modern family life into practical insight for parents.
Read Next: The Parenting Stance Under Pressure: Design, Curiosity, and Empathy | Helping Children Manage Stress
